Time to put the “Grim” back into the Grimm Brother’s Fairy Tales



Once upon a time a boy and his little brother were pretending to be a butcher and a pig. The older brother slices the younger’s throat, only to be stabbed in the heart by his enraged mother. Unfortunately, while she was stabbing her son, another one of her children drowns in a bath tub. So then she hangs herself. When dad gets home, he’s so depressed that he soon dies afterwords.

Now this might sound like the content of a death metal video, but this is actually one of the original tales from The Grimm’s Brother Fairy Tales. Jacob (1785–1863) and Wilhelm Grimm (1786–1859), were German academics, linguists, cultural researchers, lexicographers and authors who together specialized in collecting and publishing folklore during the 19th century. They are particularly famous for tales such as “Cinderella,” “The Frog Prince,” “Hansel and Gretel,” “Rapunzel” and “Snow White.”

Recently, Jack Zipes, a professor of German and comparative literature at the University of Minnesota, began to explore why the first edition of the tales had never been translated into English, and decided, eventually, to do it himself. “Though the Grimms kept about 100 of the tales from the first edition, they changed them a good deal. So, the versions with which most English-speaking (and German-speaking) readers are familiar are quite different from the tales in the first edition,” he told the Guardian.


His newly published version of the original 156 stories is just out from Princeton University Press, illustrated by Andrea Dezsö, and shows a much darker side to well-known fairy tales. Several more gruesome stories, like the Butcher and Pig tale, are added back into the edition. Zipes also adds the original versions of our well known fairy tales. The evil queen who wants Snow White killed is actually her mother, Rapunzel gets impregnated by the prince after having a “merry time” with him in the tower, Hansel and Gretel were abandoned by their own mothers, and Cinderella’s step sisters cut off their toes in order to make the slipper fit onto their feet.

So why was the English version of these tales made into a PC production, when the original tales were more R rated? One theory is that the tales were rewritten to appeal to more Middle Class, Christian Families. We can’t forget that the more PC version of the tale was also published in 1857, a time when Europeans were beginning to embrace more “Victorian Values,” which meant taking sex and violence out of the discussion, while adding Christian Values.

I remember back when I was taking a Medieval Literature class, I was surprised by how blunt most Medieval literature was about matters of sex and violence – even during an era when the Christian Church was the predominant authority. In the Canterbury Tales, The Wife of Bath remarries 5 times and brags about how she sexually dominates her much younger husbands in the bedroom. In another tale, a priest comes to a woman’s window at night and asks for a kiss, she instead sticks her ass out of the window and he gives her an accidental rim job.Once he realizes what he had done, he proclaims “I did not know my lady had a beard!” If this isn’t scandalous enough, the young lady in this tale was also cheating on her husband with a younger lover. The next night the priest comes back to get revenge on the young lady, but unexpectedly, her young lover who was with her at the time sticks his rear end out of the window and the priest shoves a burning hot poker where the sun don’t shine.


This is not to mention that many Anglo Saxon inspired Medieval Tales had enough violence to make a Quentin Tarantino movie look G-Rated. Such as one tale I read about a Prince who rescues his princess from being married off to another, he interrupts the wedding, massacres all the guests along with the groom, and then rides away with his beloved.

So you have to understand that before The Victorian Era, much of the Folk Tales of the common people were rife with blunt sexuality and violence. It is also believed that the common child was less sheltered from such brutal realities. In terms of sex, before the Industrial Era, a majority of people lived on farms in close living quarters. It is here that children witnessed the realities of reproduction among their domesticated animals. The children who had to sleep in the same room as their parents were probably also more aware of natural human processes.

In terms of other realities, death was much more common in every day life before the Industrial Revolution. Because of the Industrial Revolution, the population more than doubled in London between 1750 and 1850. Before this period, population growth was relatively stable. The Industrial Revolution helped to provide more food and shelter for the masses, while also cutting down on disease, which is part of why the population exploded. Yet before this period of time, people died all the time from things like the common cold, and surviving childhood was a major accomplishment. For example, in London, between between the 16th and 18th centuries, 30% of children died before they reached the age 15. Many women also died in childbirth because midwives did not know to wash their hands, so the poor mother often got infected.

In short, it is not surprising that folk tales were rife with more carnal and morbid details. Death and reproduction were realities that the common adult and child witnessed day to day.

The common practice of shielding our children from violence and sexuality today is quite new – a Victorian innovation. Today we see this in the hysteria of parents trying to shield their children from violent video games or provocative music. Even seeing a woman’s breasts or a man’s genitals in a movie is met with outrage.

Should parents be more open with their kids about how the world really works? Perhaps such children would be less likely to get pregnant on accident, and be more prepared to face the cruel realities of the real world. Many middle class people today are sheltered, raised in a bubble where everyone gets a trophy or a fuzzy banana sticker for merely showing up, and raised to believe that the world is a nice neat place, while being totally clueless about realities such as the plight of poverty in the third world, the destruction of the environment, and the rapes and murders taking place daily in less stable countries.

Children are much wiser and made of stronger stuff than we give them credit. Perhaps it’s time we stop shielding them from the horrors of reality, and start raising them to be people who will approach and deal such adversity with courage, rather than raising cowards who won’t step an inch away from their comfort zone.


13 responses

  1. Over the years the “we can’t hurt the feelings of others” tend to chance the original so we no longer have the fear nor the lessons which the original stories taught. Sad really.

    November 14, 2014 at 1:00 pm

    • Good point. Teachers are also now not allowed to use red pen to correct mistakes, because this would “hurt the feelings of the child,” dodge ball has been taken out of school because it’s “to violent,” even though I got injured way more from Basketball and Soccer in school, then getting hit with a plush, plastic ball. Teachers are also encouraged to write glowing, optimistic reports about all their students, even if the student was a real shit that year. This sends the message that everyone is special, safe and deserves special treatment in a world without danger. Such special snowflakes are ill equipped to deal with the dark realities of the world – which may explain many of the problems of today’s world. I’m just glad my parents let me watch rated R movies and were blunt about my mistakes, helped me become an adult.

      November 14, 2014 at 1:08 pm

      • Which is why my son will never get a job nor any other kids. They quit the moment real life hits. Glad you see it too. Most people think that because I think this way I am against the US and kids. Sad really!

        November 14, 2014 at 2:18 pm

      • As someone who used to be a teacher, I saw this first hand. The worst part of the whole system is the parents though. They barely spend any time around their own kids, but cry rage at a teacher for giving their fragile little angel a B+ instead of an A, or trying to instill any kind of punishment. Parents need to work with the teachers instead of against them, and support some kind of real consequences for their actions.

        November 14, 2014 at 2:26 pm

      • I am from a family of teachers so yes, I watched this too. This was why I never taught in the public or private schools. I take on students one at a time. 🙂

        November 14, 2014 at 3:03 pm

  2. I don’t really have a whole lot to say other than your article pretty much made the sort of points I would in one of my regular blog articles and for -that-, I thank you. Also glad someone else feels, perhaps, a bit the same way I do on child-raising and such. Lastly, thank you for sharing the tid-bit about the Grimm’s Fairytale stuff, way cool.

    November 14, 2014 at 10:03 pm

  3. Reblogged this on The Musings of Lady Gwendolynn.

    November 14, 2014 at 10:08 pm

  4. anders

    There is a need to teach Children to Think for themselves: not this outcome-based we call school today. Maybe back to basics?

    November 15, 2014 at 4:32 am

  5. anders

    November 15, 2014 at 4:48 am

  6. anders

    OT but relevant, and at the same time by conventional standards R-rated:

    November 15, 2014 at 5:39 am

  7. anders

    wrong link in last comment, please edit:

    November 15, 2014 at 11:53 am

  8. hocuspocus13

    Reblogged this on hocuspocus13 and commented:
    jinxx xoxo

    November 26, 2014 at 8:15 am

  9. You know,

    There is also a “trend” in bringing back good ‘ol Krampus, and the stories to be told about him. – Bad children – Beware!

    November 28, 2014 at 2:06 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.